Hozom’s comment: “Fair’s Fair” http://www.thenation.com/blog/167953/fairs-fair
Hot and Trazom deconstruct the argument over "fairness" in cryptic cluing. A frequent cause of complaints from solvers is when a clue doesn't clearly separate definition and wordplay, or if a solving step is ambiguously indicated. This is really a separate question from the other big complaint cause: puns and other clues that follow British rather than US rules.
Here Hot and Trazom admit that they were attempting to push the envelope a little bit with their clue " Generous one moving in two pieces of furniture (10)" in 3239, and wanted to see how the audience would react.
My view? This series of puzzles is not intended to be easy: it fills the gap between starter cryptics like you see in Games or the National Post, and those written for NPL members and other true connoisseurs. If Hot and Trazom can stretch the solvers' minds a little every week, pretty soon they'll be clamoring for more. That's good for our pastime.
Where would I draw the line? No more than one or two envelope-pushers a week, and only if the crossing letters and definition make finding the answer easier. If the solver gets the word but not necessarily the cluing, s/he can work backwards to understand how the clue was intended to work.
Hot and Trazom deconstruct the argument over "fairness" in cryptic cluing. A frequent cause of complaints from solvers is when a clue doesn't clearly separate definition and wordplay, or if a solving step is ambiguously indicated. This is really a separate question from the other big complaint cause: puns and other clues that follow British rather than US rules.
Here Hot and Trazom admit that they were attempting to push the envelope a little bit with their clue " Generous one moving in two pieces of furniture (10)" in 3239, and wanted to see how the audience would react.
My view? This series of puzzles is not intended to be easy: it fills the gap between starter cryptics like you see in Games or the National Post, and those written for NPL members and other true connoisseurs. If Hot and Trazom can stretch the solvers' minds a little every week, pretty soon they'll be clamoring for more. That's good for our pastime.
Where would I draw the line? No more than one or two envelope-pushers a week, and only if the crossing letters and definition make finding the answer easier. If the solver gets the word but not necessarily the cluing, s/he can work backwards to understand how the clue was intended to work.
Themework: 38%–kind of petered out when it got to the downs. I guess spring can really hang you up the most...
Difficulty (by standards of this weekly puzzle): average.
Political
content: 7d–Clever teasing of “birthers”, 21d–Clever teasing of Antonin Scalia
(I wonder what he prefers to drink…)
Legend: "*" anagram; "~" sounds like;
"<" letters reversed; "( )" letters inserted;
"_" letters deleted; "†" explicit in the clue, “^” first
letter or letters, “{“ relocated letter or letters
Across
1a
|
*OR (I) GINATE
|
I (“one”) contained in (“found within”) *A ROGET IN (anagram indicated by
“riffling”)
|
6a
|
PO | PUP
|
PO (“post office”) + PUP (“dog”)
|
9a
|
<TOS< | SPOT
|
<SOT< (“drunkard”, reversal indicated by “comes
back”) + SPOT (“to see”)
|
10a
|
<P (ROC) EED<
|
<DEEP< (“sea”, reversal indicated by
“returning”) containing ROC (“mythical bird”)
|
11a
|
C (*REAT) URE
|
CURE (“preserve”) containing (“adopts”) *RATE (anagram
indicated by “adjustable”)
|
12a
|
D (E) RIVE
|
DRIVE (“go for a spin”) containing (“around”) ^E^gypt
|
14a
|
*LEAP
|
*PALE (anagram indicated by “awfully”)
|
16a
|
WAL (*L STREE) T
|
*LESTER (anagram indicated by “is miscast” contained
in (“in”) WALT (“Disney”)
Good piece of misdirection in this clue: at first, you
might try and connect “Disney” with “movie.”
|
19a
|
*YESTERDAY
|
*DEFINITELY (anagram indicated by “strayed off track”)
|
20a
|
STEM
|
Double definition
|
22a
|
P | OUNCE
|
P (piano: “softly”) + OUNCE (“a little weight”)
|
23a
|
*VITAMINS
|
*NATIVISM (anagram indicated by “wrecked”)
|
26a
|
*CITADEL
|
*DIALECT (anagram indicated by “in translation”)
|
27a
|
{E{MANATE
|
MANATE{E{ (“marine mammal” relocation indicated by
“shifting tail forward”)
|
28a
|
S | IDES
|
^S^pring + IDES (“March 15”)
|
29a
|
*WINDSWEPT
|
*SHED TEARS (anagram indicated by “snakes” [I don’t
think that was grammatically precise])
|
Down
1d
|
*OPTICALLY
|
*A CITY POLL (anagram indicated by “misconstrue”)
|
2d
|
IS | SUE
|
IS (“exists”) + SUE (“go to court”)
|
3d
|
*IMPUTE
|
*UPTIME (anagram indicated by “unfairly”)
|
4d
|
*AFTER (WARD) S
|
*FASTER (anagram indicated by “surprisingly”)
containing (“keeping”) WARD (“guard”)
|
5d
|
EXPO
|
complEX POetry (container indicated by “incorporating”
|
6d
|
P | RO (PERT) Y
|
^P^ainter + ROY (“Lichtenstein”) containing (“captures”)
PERT (“saucy”)
Roy Lichtenstein (1923-1977) was a major figure in Pop
Art, who often adopted the style of comic books for his paintings.
|
7d
|
PRES (ID) ENT
|
PRESENT (“here”) containing (“concealing”) ID (“birth
certificate, perhaps”)
|
8d
|
*PADRE
|
*DRAPE (anagram indicated by “wrinkled”)
|
13d
|
*CLAY PIGEON
|
*LA COP EYING (anagram indicated by “suspicious”)
|
15d
|
AS | SAUL | TED
|
AS (“like”) + SAUL (“first ruler of Israel”) + TED
(“Turner”)
|
17d
|
T (<IME S<) HE _m_ET
|
<SEMI< (“truck”, reversal indicated by “in
reverse”) contained in (“breaks through”) †THE _m_ET (omission indicated by
“missing the start”)
|
18d
|
DE (I) CIDES
|
DECIDES (“chooses”) containing (“to restrict”)
^I^mpious
|
21d
|
*CALAIS
|
*SCALIA (anagram indicated by “drunk”)
Antonin Scalia, US Supreme Court justice, 1986 to
present
|
22d
|
~PACKS
|
~PAX (“peace”, homonym indicated by “to proclaim”)
|
24d
|
IN AN E
|
Inversion: “goose” ends “in an e”
|
25d
|
<FLOW<
|
<WOLF< (“carnivorous” [answer 11], reversal
indicated by “rises”
|
No comments:
Post a Comment
If you're responding to a hint request, please remember not to give more information than necessary. More direct hints are allowed after Monday.