As currently posted, the typesetters misnumbered the clues to 20a (shown as 21a) and 21a (shown as 22a), but those are the only errors in the puzzle. I repeat, those are the only errors. This comes on the heels of a clue (12d) being omitted from Richard Maltby's puzzle in the November Harper's, and my not finding the theme in last week's puzzle, so it proves we're all human. And as Ian told us at training camp, perfection is elusive but excellence is not.
Link to puzzle: http://www.thenation.com/article/170780/puzzle-no-3258
Degree of difficulty: hard, but no obscure words.
Hozom's comment: In Defense of Simplicity: in which Hot and Trazom explain why you shouldn't set a cryptic where all the clues are hard (at least not for a general audience like that of The Nation). Once you've got the solvers hooked and reeled into the National Puzzlers' League, anything (and everything) goes!
I'm entirely in agreement. First of all, it's good to have puzzles you can put down and pick up and not have to devote 100 percent of your mindpower to. The National Post cryptic fits that bill perfectly for me, so I solved this week's between rounds at the fencing tournament Ssaber was competing in Sunday. A couple of the other competitors were curious, so I showed them a couple of the easy clues and how they were solved. They seemed to get it, and I promised to bring them a copy of their own next time.
Political content: Name check of a The Nation colleague at 7d, with a coinage for the old-school liberalism, 25a
Composer reference: 17a
Solution and annotation below the fold
Legend: "*" anagram; "~" sounds like;
"<" letters reversed; "( )" letters inserted;
"_" or lower case: letters deleted; "†" explicit in the
clue, “^” first letter or letters, “{“ relocated letter or letters
Across
1a
|
STAFF OF LIFE
|
Pun on the staff of Life Magazine
|
8a
|
{S{ATCHE}L}
|
}L}ATCHE{S{ (“closes”, exchange of first and last
letters indicated by “switching front and back”
|
9a
|
A(V_E)NGER
|
ANGER (“[Hulk’s] defining characteristic”) containing
(“supressing”) V_iolenc_E (first and last letters indicated by “external
manifestations”)
|
10a
|
F AS TEN
|
Visual pun involving the clue number: “F” substituted
for the “10”
|
11a
|
T(HEIST)IC
|
TIC (“jerk”) containing (“took on”) HEIST (“armed
robbery”)
|
13a
|
CAN(<DELAB | R<)A
|
CANA (“biblical village”) containing (“in”) R_abbi (no
indicator for first letter) + BALED (“bundled”), (reversal indicated by
“returning”)
I think the constructors tried too hard to make this
clue work on a third level by using “rabbi” to indicate “R.”
|
15a
|
HAIL
|
Double definition
|
16a
|
A_R | CH_
|
A_i_R + CH_i_ AIR and CHI are the “basic elements” (I got this one!), omission of “i” indicated by “eliminating ignorance at the
beginning”
|
17a
|
UND(*ERVAL)UE
|
*RAVEL (anagram indicated by “composition”) contained
in (“in … setting”) UNDUE (“inappropriate”)
I was trying to make “Bolero” work at first.
|
20a
|
KINK | A | JOU_
|
KINK (“unusual erotic preference”) + A + JOU_r (“a
day” in French, omission of last letter indicated by “largely”)
Note this is the first of two clues which were
misnumbered.
|
21a
|
*ANTHEM
|
*THE MAN (anagram indicated by “overthrow”)
Also misnumbered.
|
24a
|
_RO_MAINE
|
c_RO_p (middle letters indicated by “inside”) + MAINE
(“state”)
|
25a
|
ALSO RAN
|
urALS OR ANdes (hidden words indicated by “spotted
in”)
|
26a
|
SHORT (CHANG) E
|
CHANG (“siamese twin”) contined in (“taken in by”)
SHORT E (sound of the ‘e’ in “debt”)
The original “Siamese Twins” of 19th
century sideshow fame were named Chang and Eng Bunker.
|
Down
1d
|
S_ATES
|
S_l_ATES (“lists of candidates”, omission of L
indicated by “without a hint of logrolling”)
“Logrolling” in its political sense is an agreement
between two incumbent lawmakers to support each other’s relelection
|
2d
|
*ATHLETE
|
*THE TALE (anagram indicated by “revised”)
|
3d
|
FILE
|
Double definition
|
4d
|
FEAT | HER BED
|
HERBED (“seasoned”) following (“forming the basis
for”) FEAT (“accomplishment”)
|
5d
|
_IBERIA
|
s_IBERIA (“Russian region”, omission of S indicated by
“Switzerland’s leader departs”)
|
6d
|
*EIGHT BALL
|
*BIG LETHAL (anagram indicated by “terrible”)
|
7d
|
ERIC ALTERMAN
|
chimERICAL TERM ANtineoliberalism (hidden name
indicated by “captivated by”)
|
8d
|
SAFECRACKERS
|
Heteronym: safe crackers
|
12d
|
RA (IN FO) REST
|
INFO (“dope”) contained in (“found in”) RAREST (“most
uncommon”)
The #3 definition of “dope”: constructors sometimes
use it as a polite and non-animal clue to “ass”)
|
14d
|
*NICKNAMES
|
*MANIC KEN’S (anagram indicated by “mangled”)
|
18d
|
<_VEN< | IS ON
|
<NEV_ada< (omission and reversal indicated by “halfback”)
+ IS ON (“performs”)
|
19d
|
CA | SIN | O
|
CA (“California”) + SIN (“transgression”) + O (“love”)
|
22d
|
~HORSE
|
~HOARSE (“grating”, homonym indicated by “to the ear”)
|
23d
|
BAT | H
|
BAT (“club”) + H (“hot”)
|
No comments:
Post a Comment
If you're responding to a hint request, please remember not to give more information than necessary. More direct hints are allowed after Monday.